Former Ruto Lawyer Addresses Bias Concerns in Supreme Court Bid

Court of Appeal Judge Katwa Kigen told the Judicial Service Commission he would remain impartial if appointed to the Supreme Court, despite concerns about his past role as President William Ruto’s lawyer.

Appearing before the commission on 28 April at the Milimani Law Courts, Kigen was questioned about whether his previous representation of the President could affect his neutrality, particularly in a potential presidential petition after the 2027 General Election. The issue followed a letter submitted to the commission on 8 April 2026 raising concerns about his suitability.

Justice Fatuma Sichale asked Kigen to address public concerns directly. In response, he acknowledged his professional relationship with Ruto but said his decisions would be guided strictly by the law and evidence. He stated that he would act objectively and fairly in all cases.

Kigen said his past work as an advocate should not be used against him, noting that many judges have represented clients before joining the bench. He argued that singling him out on this basis would be discriminatory. He also pointed to existing judicial safeguards, including the option for judges to recuse themselves where there is a valid concern about conflict of interest.

He further noted that the Supreme Court handles a wide range of matters beyond presidential petitions, and that such cases have previously been heard by fewer than all seven judges. He urged the commission to assess his integrity and professional record rather than his former clients.

Kigen is among several senior judges competing for the vacancy.